Search Results

Events & Tickets We've always got something fun up our sleeve! Ice Cream Truck Catering Venue Rental Fundraisers Dinner Theatres Thankgiving Meal Pre-Orders Time & Location Pre-orders close Nov 22. Pick-up on Wed, Nov 26 between 3-5pm at Lickity Split. Menu Meals are fully cooked and come ready to reheat in disposable pans with instructions. Choose from Family Size or Individual Meals. Limited quantities available. Pre-Order Now Ice Cream Truck Events Time & Location Visit the Lickity Split Ice Cream Truck Facebook Page for a list of our public events that you can find us at! About the Event Our menu varies at our public ice cream truck events. We accept both cash, card, googlepay, and applepay. Find Events Ice Cream for Breakfast Time & Location Saturday, February 7 | 8:00 AM - 11:00 AM Lickity Split Restaurant, 209 E. Main Street, New Holland About the Event Join us for one of our favorite holidays - National Eat Ice Cream for Breakfast! Yes - we have an exclusive breakfast menu! More Info Ice Cream for Breakfast Time & Location Sunday, March 22 | 2:00 PM - 5:00 PM Lickity Split Restaurant, 209 E. Main Street, New Holland About the Event Celebrate the arrival of Spring with a FREE petite scoop of ice cream at Lickity Split Restaurant. Bring your family and friends! More Info

Need food or a venue for an upcoming event? Let us help! From simple catering with boxed meals and platters of wraps or formal catering to hosting your next event in our ground floor restaurant or lower level private event space - we have it all! Catering & Venue Need food or a venue for an upcoming event? Let us help! Venue Rental & Catering Inquiry Form Thanksgiving Meal Pre-Orders Boxed Meals & Wrap Platters Formal Catering Event Space Venue PDF Download - Simple Catering Menu Contact Gail at UlrichG@Live.com or the restaurant phone at 717-354-4986 for inquiries and ordering. Platter of Wraps Easily feed a group with platters of our most popular wraps cut and wrapped in deli paper. Please give us a 48-hour notice. Add bags of chips and pickles on the side for an additional charge. Boxed Meals Individually boxed meals make for quick, easy food for a group! Perfect for a delicious lunch for any occasion. Each meal includes: a popular wrap from our restaurant, kettle-cooked chips, and a dill pickle. Please give us a 48-hour notice. PDF Download - Formal Catering Menu Contact our team at LickitySplitNewHolland@gmail.com for availability and inquiries. PDF Download - Venue Rental Pricing This historical venue is the answer for a unique location for your next event. Birthday Party Christmas Parties Baby Shower Bridal Shower Work Event Surprise Parties Intimate Wedding Ceremony Rehearsal Dinner Staff Lunch Retirement Party Family Meal

Events & Tickets We've always got something FUN up our sleeve! Ice Cream Truck Catering Venue Rental Fundraisers Dinner Theatres

Lickity Split is a family-friendly restaurant and ice cream shop that is great for lunch and dinner in New Holland, PA. Both locals and Lancaster County tourists love to experience where nostalgia meets good eats and great times! Where Nostalgia Meets Good Eats and Great Times. 1/33 Lickity Split Order Online View Menu Turkey & Waffles Platter I Every Wednesday 11-7PM Dine. Local Eats & Sweet Treats From fresh roasted turkey melts to house-made stuffed pretzels and expansive ice cream offerings, our menu offers a delightful experience for every palate. Learn More Have Fun. Tickets for Private Events From themed dinners to creative workshops, there’s always something happening at Lickity Split! Our ticketed events—like murder mystery dinners, charcuterie classes, paint nights, and more—bring food, fun, and community together in unforgettable ways. Whether you're learning a new skill, solving a mystery, or just enjoying a night out, our events are designed to make memories worth sharing. Buy Event Tickets New Holland's First Escape Room The notorious Buzzard Gang is known throughout Lancaster County for their extensive crime sprees, legendary jailbreaks, and deadly reputation. The FBI needs your hep to capture these dangerous men who are on the loose. You team has 60 minutes to find clues, follow the trail, and capture the escapees. Can you group do it before time runs out? Escape Room Adventure Make Memories. Create unforgettable memories with a food truck everyone will love! The Ice Cream Cart or Truck is perfect for any event! Weddings, birthdays, employee appreciation, company picnics, schools, and church events! Ice Cream Fun Join Us at Lickity Split Location 209 E. Main St New Holland, PA 17557 View in Maps Restaurant Hours Monday-Saturday 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM Closed Sunday Escape Room Hours Escape Room Reservations are available by Appointment Only by email or online booking.

Step back in time at Lickity Split Restaurant – a family-owned gem nestled in a restored 1800s building where great food, local charm, and old-fashioned hospitality come together. We serve cozy lunches, delicious dinners, and sweet treats with a side of nostalgia. The Lickity Split Story Step back in time at Lickity Split Restaurant – a family-owned gem nestled in a restored 1800s building where great food, local charm, and old-fashioned hospitality come together. We serve cozy lunches, delicious dinners, and sweet treats with a side of nostalgia. Our Story FAQ's Contact Us Join Our Team Whether you're seeking a few shifts a week or need a change of pace from your field of work, we have the perfect opportunity for you. We're always accepting applications! Apply Here

The Lickity Split ice cream truck and cart is perfect for weddings, birthday parties, employee appreciation, company picnics, festivals, car shows, school events, church events, and more. All ice cream truck and ice cream cart pricing can be found on our website. Each event has a minimum sales requirement. We also provide tips for booking food trucks so that your event runs smoothly. For all ice cream truck and ice cream cart inquiries, complete our form, and we will be in contact with you. Ice Cream Truck & Cart For all Ice Cream Cart and Ice Cream Truck inquiries, complete the form below. *Please do not call the restaurant for ice cream truck information. Booking Inquiry Form Cart & Truck Perfect For: *Weddings *Birthday Parties *Employee Appreciation *Company Picnics *Festivals & Car Show *School Events *Church Events Pricing Info Each event has a minimum sales requirement. View pricing below. PDF: Ice Cream TRUCK PDF: Ice Cream CART LickitySplitIceCreamTruck@yahoo.com Food Truck Resources Make your event run smoothly! PDF: 22 Tips for Booking Food Trucks PDF: Ice Cream Truck Common Questions & General Info

Mystery Dinner Theatre We team up with theatre companies to present an unforgettable experience! Laugh along with the cast and try to help them figure out "whodunit." Participate in the fun or sit back, relax, and enjoy the show! Buy Tickets Upcoming Dates: Saturday, December 6 at 6:00 PM Theme: Dickens of a Murder Menu*: Appetizers Main Entree - Cheesy Chicken Bacon Ranch, Mashed Potatoes, Roasted Carrots Dessert Varieties Holiday Punch, Decaf Coffee, and Water *Please note we are unable to adjust our menu to suit individual diet preferences How does a Dinner Theatre work? Look for the hidden clues, take an audience participation script, or ask the suspects any questions you like. Prefer to quietly enjoy the show? No problem! Sit back and relax and watch the mystery unfold. Characters will mingle to help you figure out whodunnit. Maybe you'll figure it out too? Wear an outfit to fit the theme if you like, or come as you are - either way, join the fun! (PG-rating) Ticket Includes: Theatre entertainment, food, and drinks* 6:00pm - Event Please do not arrive more than 15 minutes early so the actors can finish preparing. GOOD TO KNOW - DINNER THEATRE: No physical ticket will be sent, just give your name to the host upon entrance. Parking is available in the Trinity Church parking lot located next door at 221 E. Main Street, New Holland. Entrance - Please enter our event space from the front sidewalk on MAIN STREET and down the front steps to the lower-leverl space. Note that it is NOT handicapped accessible. Seating is assigned by event staff and "family style" - so depending on your group size you may be seated with other event attendees. Tickets are non-refundable if less than 1 week before the event date. Advance reservations and payment are required. Buy Tickets

Get answers to all the frequently asked questions about Lickity Split, our dining experience, events, catering, ice cream truck and cart, escape room, and job opportunities with Lickity Split. Frequently Asked Questions About Lickity Split What’s the story behind Lickity Split? Lickity Split started as a little red ice cream truck in 2006, run by Mitch and Gina Dissinger. They are both New Holland natives and Garden Spot High School alumni. It quickly became a local favorite, and by 2010, they restored part of New Holland’s historic Kauffman’s Hardware building and opened the full restaurant. We’ve been growing ever since—with great food, cozy vibes, and deep New Holland roots. It’s a true family-run business built on love for good food and great people. Read more of our story here. Why is there so much New Holland memorabilia in the restaurant? Owner Mitch Dissinger is a lifelong New Holland local with a serious passion for hometown history. Much of what you see on the walls is from his personal collection—a nostalgic tribute to the people, places, and stories that make this town special. Mitch is also the Co-Founder of the New Holland Area Historical Society , which is just next door to Lickity Split. They are open Thursday and Saturday from 10:00am - 2:00pm. Is it true there’s a real jail cell under the restaurant? Yes! Our building once housed the town's single cell lock-up jail , and the original 1868 jail cell still exists in our basement. It’s been preserved and even plays a role in our escape room experience. History lovers and puzzle solvers alike are in for a real treat! If you ask during a break in our service, one of our staff can take you down to check it out. It's a great photo op! What are your hours? The restaurant is open Monday through Saturday, 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM. Closed Sundays. Hours are by appointment only for the Escape Room. For daily updates or schedule changes, check our Facebook Page or call the restaurant at 717-354-4986. Where are you located? Our address is 209 E Main Street, New Holland, PA —right in the heart of town, in a beautifully restored 1800s building. Do you have parking? Yes! There’s a public parking lot behind the restaurant (off of N Railroad Ave) and plenty of street parking nearby. Overflow parking is available next door at Trinity Lutheran Church (221 E Main Street, New Holland). Do you make donations? We are able to make a limited number of donations per year. To request a donation for your event, classroom, or fundraiser, please fill out our donation request form here. Is it true you've won awards and been on a restaurant episode? Yes! We’ve been honored with multiple local “Best Of” awards over the years and were proudly featured on America’s Best Restaurants in 2024. Where can I watch your America’s Best Restaurants episode? You can watch the full episode here and see why our food, atmosphere, and escape room wowed the ABR team! Dining Experience Do you accept reservations? We operate on a first-come, first-served basis. If you’re coming with a large group (7 or more), give us a call at 717-354-4986 and we’ll do our best to prepare for you. Are you family-friendly? Absolutely! Kids love the fun, cozy vibe—and our kid’s menu, ice cream treats, and friendly staff make it a hit for the whole family. Plus we have coloring sheets and a shelf of books and games to enjoy while you dine! Do you offer high chairs or booster seats? Yes, we’ve got both available. Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible? Yes, our space is fully accessible—including our restrooms. What menu items are you known for? Definitely our dill pickle soup, pretzel melts, hand-carved turkey sandwiches, homemade soups, and turkey & waffles. And don’t forget the ice cream sundaes! Vew our menus here. Wait, what exactly is the Dill Pickle Soup? Glad you asked! It's a cream of potato base with cooked carrots, diced dill pickles, and a kick of Old Bay Seasoning! Even if pickles aren't you're thing - it's worth trying! What is The Stan Deen Combo? In early 2025 we launched a new menu item, The Stan Deen Combo, featuring half a Garden Spot Melt, a cup of Chicken Corn Noodle, and a petite scoop of Milky Way ice cream. A portion of each Stan Deen Combo sold ($2!) will be donated to The Stan Deen Foundation . The Stan Deen Foundation exists to empower vulnerable youth through education and the arts. By partnering with local and national foundations, we seek to improve the quality of life for beneficiaries by investing in their education, artistic abilities, and mental health to build resilient, better informed, and more engaged individuals. Lickity Split owners, Mitch & Gina, are proud to be able to support this Foundation in honor of Stan and the personal connection they had with him. Stan was a Lancaster County institution—beloved by generations of students and adults throughout the area and beyond. Stan’s remarkable life transformed countless individuals. With a seemingly endless supply of energy, enthusiasm, and optimism, all highlighted by his distinctive wit and charm, Stan truly lived each day to its fullest. His zest for life was unmatched, and he shared his joy with every person who crossed his path. Stan was at his best when he was bringing out the best in others. “If there is anything I could really encourage you all to do is have some visions and dreams for what you can become. Because everybody has been given certain abilities, certain talents and aspirations, and I would hope that you would use those to their fullest, wherever you go.” – Stan Deen Do you accommodate food allergies or dietary restrictions? We do our best! Just let a staff member know when you order and mention whether it's an allergy or a choice. We also offer gluten-free ice cream cones and dairy-free ice cream options. All of our sandwiches and wraps can also be made on gluten-free bread or a gluten-free wrap. What brand of ice cream do you serve? We serve hand-dipped, premium-quality ice cream from Leiby’s—a Tamaqua, PA favorite with that old-fashioned flavor you love. Can I order online? Yes! Click here to order online for pickup. Do you offer gift cards? Sure do—stop in to purchase, order on our website, or give us a call at 717-354-4986! Can I celebrate a birthday at Lickity Split? Of course! We’re a popular spot for birthday meals and desserts—and we also host private events if you’re planning something bigger. Plus you get a FREE BIRTHDAY SUNDAE reminder when you join our VIP Email List. Events & Catering Do you host private events or parties? Yes! Our restaurant can be transformed into a cozy first floor event space that’s perfect for showers, rehearsal dinners, birthdays, retirement parties, and more on Sundays when the restaurant is closed. Plus, we have a private venue space in the lower level that is available for bookings any day of the week! Learn more here. How do I inquire about event rentals or catering? Just fill out our event rental and catering inquiry form or give us a call—we’ll help you plan something special. What kinds of events do you cater? We do small meetings, corporate lunches, parties, and more. Our team loves being a part of your special events—big or small!. Do you offer off-site catering? Yes, we can assemble trays of food for you to pick-up and use at your off-site gathering. Pricing info can be found here. Is outside food or cake allowed for events? Yes, for private parties in our event space, you’re welcome to bring your own cake or special items. Just let us know in advance. Ice Cream Truck & Cart How can I book the ice cream truck or cart? Just fill out our booking request form and we’ll get back to you with availability and pricing. What types of events does the truck or cart attend? Any and all! We do weddings, birthday parties, company events, fairs, employee appreciation, and food truck festivals all across Lancaster County. Is there a minimum to book the truck or cart? Yes—there is a minimum cost depending on distance, time, and number of servings. Pricing info can be found here . What’s the difference between the ice cream truck and the ice cream cart? The truck is great for larger events and outdoor festivals. The cart, added in 2025, is perfect for indoor set-up, during colder season, or for a more personal catering experience. Escape Room What is an escape room? It’s a live-action adventure game where your group solves puzzles and clues to complete a mission—all in under 60 minutes! Do I need to book in advance? Yes, our escape room is reservation-based. Click here to book. Is it kid-friendly? The experience is best for ages 12 and up. It’s not scary, just full of puzzles, teamwork, and fun. How many people can play at once? Groups of 4–8 are ideal. However, we suggest a max of 15 people. Is it wheelchair accessible? We regret to share that it is not wheelchair accessible. Guests enter our event space from the front sidewalk on MAIN STREET and down the front steps to the lower-level space. Is the escape room inside the restaurant? No - it's actually underneath! We have a private event space in the lower level and have incorporated the Escape Room experience throughout the room! This is also the location of the original 1800s jail cell inside our building—one of the most unique escape room features around. Careers Are you hiring? How can I apply? We’re always looking for great people to join our team! Stop in for an application or fill out an online application. We’d love to meet you. Apply now! What’s it like to work at Lickity Split? Fun, fast-paced, friendly, and full of flavor! Many of our team members stay for years because it’s more than a job—it’s a family. Request a Donation Please submit your donation request at the link below. Donation Request

Get in touch with Lickity Split by submitting a contact form, calling the restaurant, emailing our team, visiting in person, or following our social media pages on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok. Get In Touch with Lickity Split Visit our social media for daily updates! First name* Last name* Email* Yes, subscribe me to your newsletter. Message* Submit Visit Us 209 E. Main Street New Holland, PA 17557 Email Us LickitySplitNewHolland@gmail.com Call Us 717-354-4986 (Restaurant) Connect with Us Join our Team We're always accepting applications! Apply Now

Our Escape Room is located in New Holland, PA about 15 minutes outside of Lancaster City. This is an excellent teamwork opportunity for staff development, a unique way to celebrate a special occasion, or something challenging and memorable to do while on vacation in Lancaster County. Whether you love history, a good puzzle, or just a good time with friends, family, or co-workers, this is the event for you. Book Now - Escape Room New Holland's First Escape Room Our Escape Room is located in New Holland, PA about 15 minutes outside of Lancaster City. This is an excellent teamwork opportunity for staff development, a unique way to celebrate a special occasion, or something challenging and memorable to do while on vacation in Lancaster County! Whether you love history, a good puzzle, or just a good time with friends, family, or co-workers, this is the event for you. Our design team spent many months developing this experience and based the storyline on historical facts as much as possible. Yes - the Buzzard Gang was a REAL group of criminals that lived in this area! You'll even see copies of their actual mugshots, handwritten letters from when they were in jail, and learn about how they performed one of, if not the most, creative jailbreaks in the history of Lancaster County Prison. And it involved a canary! Get ready for an unforgettable, challenging experience that'll have you talking about it long after your 60 minutes are up! Ticket Includes: Admission for up to 6 people and an unforgettable experience based on local, historical events! Packages start at 225.00 and include admittance for up to 6 people. Add on up to 9 more group members at 25.00 each. For a custom booking date/time, contact us at LickitySplitNewHolland@gmail.com Book Now! The Experience Our escape room is an adventure game where your group works together to solve puzzles, uncover clues, and complete a mission—all within 60 minutes. It’s a fun, interactive experience designed for teamwork, creativity, and a little bit of brainpower! Are you really locked in? Nope! You're not trying to escape, your goup's mission is to find five prison escapees. Difficulty Level = Easy or Hard, it's up to you! Solve it without using a hint or utilize unlimited hints from your Escape Room Experience host. You choose! The Story The notorious Buzzard Gang was known throughout Lancaster County for their extensive crime sprees, legendary jailbreaks, and deadly reputation. The FBI needs your help to capture these dangerous men who are on the loose. Can your group find them in time? Buzzard Gang History Good to Know 60 minutes to Solve the Mystery - find and capture members of the Buzzard Gang. Can you beat the record? 15-minute early arrival for your mystery-solving debriefing (do not enter any earlier) Parking - available in the Trinity Church Parking lot located next door at 221 E. Main Street, New Holland. Entrance - Please enter our event space from the front sidewalk on MAIN STREET and down the front steps to the lower-level space. Note that it is NOT handicapped accessible Reservations - Reservations are required and must be made a minimum of 48 hours in advance. No Walk-ins. Got questions? Contact us at LickitySplitNewHolland@gmail.com Book Now

Visit the restaurant, view Lunch & Dinner Menu, Kids Menu, and Dessert Menu. Take a virtual walk-through of the restaurant and get the low down on parking available in the lot behind our building. Our main entrance is in the rear and connected to the parking lot and is handicapped accessible. Visit the Restaurant Scroll down to view MENUS or click below to view PDF's Lunch & Dinner Menu Dessert Menu Kids Menu WALK-THROUGH! Take a walk through our restaurant by viewing the video below! Virtual Visit PARKING Parking is available in the lot behind our building, located off of Railroad Ave. Parking Lot ACCESSIBLE Our main entrance (in the rear, connected to the parking lot) has a ramp entrance and is handicapped accessible. Lunch & Dinner Menu Dessert Menu Lunch & Dinner Menu Served Monday-Saturday, 11am - 7pm APPETIZERS PRETZEL NUGGETS fifteen soft pretzel nuggets served with cheddar cheese sauce and cranberry honey mustard for dipping $7.99 NACHOS tortilla chips topped with melted cheese and served with sour cream and salsa on the side $6.49 CHIPS & SALSA bowl of tortilla chips and a side of salsa $4.49 PA DUTCH PLATTER platter of leaf lettuce with chicken salad, a variety of sliced cheeses, a red beet egg, red beets, sweet bologna, and crackers $9.49 SALAD ORCHARD mandarin oranges, apples, dried cranberries, sliced almond, and cucumbers on a bed of garden fresh greens served with Poppy Seed dressing $11.99 CAESAR seasoned croutons, fresh parmesan, and Caesar dressing on a bed of romaine $10.99 LICKITY SPLIT SALAD tomatoes, cucumbers, shredded cheese, and potato sticks on a bed of garden fresh greens $12 SPRING HOUSE dried cranberries, sliced almonds, tomatoes, and onions on a bed of garden fresh greens $10.99 CHEF mixed greens, turkey, ham, swiss cheese, red beet egg, tomatoes, and croutons $14.99 HALF-SIZE SALAD excludes the Chef Salad $6.49 ADD PROTEIN Grilled Chicken $4.99 Buffalo Chicken $5.49 Fresh Roasted Turkey $4.49 Chicken Salad $4.99 SOUP All soups are homemade in-house with delicious, locally sourced ingredients. Daily soups include Chicken Corn Noodle and our famous Creamy Dill Pickle (ask for a sample!) CUP 7 oz. $5.99 BOWL 16 oz. $7.99 QUART frozen or hot (when available) $14.49 COMBOS Half Sandwich Combos EXCLUDE Pretzel Melts, Lickity Lou Club, Chef Salad, and the Black Bean Wrap SOUP & HALF SANDWICH includes your choice of any sandwich or wrap on the menu, chips, and a cup of soup $12.99 SALAD & HALF SANDWICH choose a small salad and sandwich or wrap $12.99 SOUP & SALAD choose a cup of soup and a small salad $11.99 UPGRADE TO A BOWL OF SOUP $1.99 HALF SANDWICH & CHIPS ONLY $7.49 DRESSINGS Ranch, Italian, Caesar, Bleu Cheese, Poppy Seed, Fat-free Raspberry Vinaigrette, 1,000 Island, Honey Mustard, Oil & Vinegar FROM THE GRILL Includes chips and pickle GARDEN SPOT MELT creamy chicken salad with bacon and cheddar cheese served on grilled ciabatta $12.99 KAUFFMAN'S CUBAN grilled ham, hard salami, swiss cheese, dill pickles, spicy brown mustard, grilled on crunchy ciabatta $12.49 TRIMMER'S TRIBUTE roasted turkey, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce, mayonnaise, apple butter and apple slices on grilled ciabatta $13.49 SALES BARN BEEF DIP roast beef, provolone cheese on a toasted steak roll served with a side of beef au jus $12.99 WEAVER'S CHICKEN grilled chicken breast, cheddar cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato and ranch or bbq dressing on a kaiser roll $13.49 BALER BEEF MELT grilled roast beef, cheddar cheese and bbq sauce on a kaiser roll $12.99 VEGGIE MELT provolone and cheddar cheese with lettuce, tomato, and cucumber on grilled deli rye with your choice of dressing $10.49 CLASSIC GRILLED CHEESE american cheese on grilled white bread $7.49 200 BLOCK GRILLED CHEESE american, provolone, and cheddar cheeses on grilled wheat bread $7.99 NEW HOLLAND GRILLER thick cut slice of sweet bologna, provolone, and cheddar cheese, with yellow mustard on grilled wheat bread $9.49 TOWN CLOCK NEWS roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, sauerkraut, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye $13.49 THE CLARION roast beef or roasted turkey, swiss cheese, homemade coleslaw, 1,000 island, grilled on deli rye $13.99 CHEESE QUESADILLA cheddar cheese melted in a grilled tortilla and served with a side of tortilla chips, sour cream, and salsa $10.99 CHICKEN QUESADILLA grilled chicken and melted cheddar cheese served with tortilla chips, sour cream, and salsa on the side $14.49 ROAST BEEF QUESADILLA roast beef and melted cheddar cheese served with chips and a side of either horseradish mayo or bbq sauce $14.49 TURKEY PESTO MELT roasted turkey, melted provolone, pesto mayo, and cranberry on grilled white bread $13.49 STUFFED PRETZEL MELT pretzel dough baked in-house and stuffed with provolone and choice of: Ham and Cheese $12.99 Cheesesteak $14.49 WRAPS Includes chips and a pickle. Choice of Wraps: Plain, Tomato Basil, or Spinach Herb RUBINSON'S our house-made creamy chicken salad with dried cranberries, sliced almonds, lettuce and tomato $13.49 GRILLED MAIN STREET grilled chipped ham, swiss cheese, sliced apples and spicy brown mustard $10.49 CHICKEN CAESAR grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, croutons and fresh parmesan cheese covered with creamy caesar dressing $13.99 WILD BUFFALO CHICKEN grilled chicken, provolone cheese, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato with a choice of bleu cheese or ranch $13.99 VEGGIE provolone cheese, cucumbers, onions, lettuce, and tomato with your choice of dressing $11.99 SMOKY BBQ CHICKEN grilled chicken breast topped with a smoky bbq sauce, cheddar cheese, and coleslaw $13.99 BLACK BEAN tex-mex rice, black beans, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, and salsa $11.99 OLD BAY CHICKEN grilled chicken breast, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and Old Bay mayonnaise $13.49 BRIMMER AVE fresh roasted turkey, crispy bacon, ranch, american cheese, lettuce, and tomato $13.49 SIGNATURE SANDWICHES Includes chips and a pickle. THANKSGIVING DAY roasted turkey, warm stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayonnaise on a kaiser roll $13.99 BLT crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on your choice of toast $10.49 RAILROAD AVENUE SUB provolone cheese, capicola ham, hard salami, lettuce, tomato, parmesan cheese, oregano, and olive oil on a sub roll $13.99 LICKITY LOU CLUB triple-decker with ham, roasted turkey, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayonnaise on your choice of toast $14.49 MONDAYS ONLY: Burger Menu Delicious black angus 1/3 lb beef burgers served on a toasted Brioche bun with a side of chips and a pickle CLASSIC HAMBURGER choose toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard, and sliced dill pickle spears $12 CLASSIC CHEESEBURGER cheese choices: American, cheddar, provolone, swiss or pepper jack cheese topping choices: lettuce, tomato, onion, mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard, sliced dill pickle spears $13 BACON CHEESEBURGER American cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and onion $14 BBQ BURGER cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, coleslaw, and tangy BBQ sauce $13.6 BACON RANCH BURGER cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, ranch dressing, lettuce, and tomato $14 MEXICAN BURGER pepper jack cheese, crushed nachos, salsa, red onion, lettuce, and tomatoes $12.6 OLD BAY BURGER pepper jack cheese, Old Bay mayo, sliced dill pickle spears, lettuce, and tomatoes $12.6 COWBOY BURGER cheddar cheese, grilled onions, bacon, ranch bbq, lettuce and tomato $13.6 PESTO MELT BURGER provolone cheese, pesto mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion $12.3 PATTY MELT melted swiss cheese and grilled onions on deli Rye bread $12.3 GRILLED CHEESEBURGER American cheese on country white bread grilled to perfection $12.3 TUESDAYS ONLY: Roast Beef Day Hot Roast Beef Sandwich served between two slices of bread smothered in beef gravy with mashed potatoes and choice of: small salad with Raspberry Vinaigrette dressing OR sides of applesauce and coleslaw $16.99 Traditional Pulled Beef Sandwich melted American with horseradish mayo or BBQ sauce $14.49 Southern Pulled Beef Sandwich melted cheddar topped with BBQ sauce and coleslaw $15.49 WEDNESDAYS ONLY: Turkey & Waffles Platter Fresh roasted turkey and gravy served over homemade waffles with sides of applesauce, mashed potatoes, coleslaw, and cranberry sauce. Regular Regular Platter includes 2 waffles. $15.49 Small Small Platter includes 1 waffle. $13.49 BUILD A SANDWICH Served with chips and a dill pickle Choose your own Bread, Meat, Cheese, Veggies, and Dressing $12.99 KIDS MENU MAIN DISH: grilled cheese, hot dog, build your own sandwich, kraft mac 'n cheese, pb & marshmallow, pb&j, or half a grilled cheese and a cup of chicken noodle soup SIDES: chips, applesauce, or carrots and celery with ranch dip KIDS DRINKS: apple juice, lemonade, milk, chocolate milk, soda Includes main dish, side, drink, and petite ice cream $7.99 Without ice cream $5.99 BEVERAGES SODA, LEMONADE & TEA Coke, Diet Coke, Root Beer, Dr Pepper, Sprite, Lemonade, Gold Peak Unsweetened Tea and Sweet Tea (refills included) $2.99 ADD a flavored syrup raspberry, cherry, peach, strawberry, vanilla, caramel, $0.49 ITALIAN SODA seltzer soda mixed with your choice of syrup: cherry, peach, raspberry, strawberry, vanilla, caramel (refills included) $2.49 STRAWBERRY PATCH LEMONADE our special mix of sweet strawberries and lemonade in a satisfying blend (1 free refill) $4.49 SHIRLEY TEMPLE old fashioned favorite made with sprite, cherry syrup and maraschino cherries (refills included) $3.49 ICED COFFEE $3.99 ICED COFFEE FLOAT house brewed iced coffee served with whole milk, vanilla ice cream, and vanilla or caramel syrup $4.99 MILK White or Chocolate $2.89 COFFEE $2.49 BOTTLED SODA $2.99 HOT CHOCOLATE $2.49 HOT TEA $1.99 MILKSHAKE $6.5

Our Story: From Ice Cream Truck to Community Favorite In 2006, Mitch and Gina Dissinger bought a little red ice cream truck from a local couple who was ready to retire. What began as a fun summer job quickly became a local hit—serving sweet treats and smiles all around New Holland and Lancaster County. Fueled by a passion for great food, friendly service, and their hometown, Mitch and Gina took the next step in 2010, restoring historic Kauffman’s Hardware building and opening the Restaurant. The Lickity Split Story Step back in time at Lickity Split Restaurant – a family-owned gem nestled in a restored 1800s building where great food, local charm, and old-fashioned hospitality come together. We serve cozy lunches, delicious dinners, and sweet treats with a side of nostalgia. Our Story: From Ice Cream Truck to Community Favorite In 2006, Mitch and Gina Dissinger bought a little red ice cream truck from a local couple who was ready to retire. What began as a fun summer job quickly became a local hit—serving sweet treats and smiles all around New Holland and Lancaster County. Fueled by a passion for great food, friendly service, and their hometown, Mitch and Gina took the next step in 2010, restoring part of the historic Kauffman’s Hardware building and opening Lickity Split Restaurant. What started as a simple soup, sandwich, and ice cream shop has since grown into a full-service restaurant known for its cozy lunches, hearty dinners, homemade specialties, and warm, nostalgic atmosphere. Their mission was simple: serve good food with genuine hospitality in a place that feels like home—and they’ve never looked back. Explore Our Menu Our Mission is to cultivate joy by serving delicious, quality food and creating a memorable experience. Events, Catering & The Sweetest Additions As Lickity Split grew, so did the number of people looking to celebrate life’s special moments with them. Hosting private events and dinner theatres in their cozy event space quickly became part of the magic. From bridal showers and baby showers to birthday parties and corporate gatherings, guests began to discover that Lickity Split was more than just a great place to eat—it was a place to make memories. Soon, catering followed—offering fresh, made-to-order meals for off-site events—and in 2025, the Ice Cream Cart made its debut, bringing Lickity Split's charm and sweetness directly to weddings, community events, and private parties across Lancaster County. Whether it’s a vintage-themed dinner theatre or a sundae bar at your reception, Lickity Split now serves joy in more ways than ever before. Our Escape Room: History Comes to Life Tucked away in the original 1800s jail cell inside the restaurant, Lickity Split’s escape room offers an experience unlike any other. Inspired by real events and designed with historic accuracy, the escape room tells the story of the Buzzard Gang—a group of Lancaster County criminals whose daring jailbreak made local legend. You’ll encounter original mugshots, authentic letters, and hands-on puzzles that bring the past to life. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, bonding with coworkers, or just looking for something fun and different to do, this 60-minute challenge is unforgettable. Come for the food, stay for the mystery—then tell everyone you escaped from jail after dinner. Escape Room Community, Connection, Food & Fun Rooted in New Holland: Community Is at Our Core At Lickity Split, community isn’t just something we serve—it’s part of who we are. Owners Mitch and Gina Dissinger, both proud Garden Spot High School graduates, have always poured their hearts into New Holland . From showcasing Mitch’s extensive New Holland memorabilia collection throughout the restaurant’s decor, to supporting local events and organizations, Lickity Split is deeply connected to the town it calls home. Sharing a building with the New Holland Historical Society and Museum , the restaurant honors the town’s past every day—and helps shape its present through fun, food, and fellowship. You’ll often spot the Lickity Split Ice Cream Truck popping up at local happenings like the July 4th fireworks, New Holland Summer Arts, the New Holland Fair, every Garden Spot home football game, and many local business events. Mitch and Gina are also founding members of the Taste of New Holland Food Fest, an annual Spring celebration of local flavor and fun supporting the Garden Spot Fire Rescue. In 2025, Lickity Split proudly partnered with the Stan Deen Foundation to celebrate the life and legacy of Stan—a true New Holland legend and difference-maker. The Stan Deen Special was added to the menu and created in his honor. For every one sold, $1 is donated directly to the Foundation to support ongoing community impact. It’s just one more way to give back to the place and people they love most. Whether it’s serving sandwiches or scooping sundaes, their goal has always been to bring a little joy wherever the road (or the ice cream truck!) may lead. As Seen on America's Best Restaurants! See behind the scenes, meet Mitch & Gina, and discover why Lickity Split is truly one of America’s Best Restaurants! In 2024, Lickity Split was honored to be featured on an episode of America’s Best Restaurants! The crew spent the day capturing what makes us special—our scratch-made menu favorites, welcoming atmosphere, rich local history, and the unforgettable experiences we create for our guests. From our fan- favorite Thanksgiving Day Sandwich to the one-of-a-kind escape room, they got to see it all! We were thrilled to share our story, our space, and our people with a national audience. Watch the Full Episode >