Frequently Asked Questions
About Lickity Split
What’s the story behind Lickity Split?
Lickity Split started as a little red ice cream truck in 2006, run by Mitch and Gina Dissinger. They are both New Holland natives and Garden Spot High School alumni. It quickly became a local favorite, and by 2010, they restored part of New Holland’s historic Kauffman’s Hardware building and opened the full restaurant. We’ve been growing ever since—with great food, cozy vibes, and deep New Holland roots. It’s a true family-run business built on love for good food and great people. Read more of our story here.
​
Why is there so much New Holland memorabilia in the restaurant?
Owner Mitch Dissinger is a lifelong New Holland local with a serious passion for hometown history. Much of what you see on the walls is from his personal collection—a nostalgic tribute to the people, places, and stories that make this town special. Mitch is also the Co-Founder of the New Holland Area Historical Society, which is just next door to Lickity Split. They are open Thursday and Saturday from 10:00am - 2:00pm.
​
Is it true there’s a real jail cell under the restaurant?
Yes! Our building once housed the town's single cell lock-up jail, and the original 1868 jail cell still exists in our basement. It’s been preserved and even plays a role in our escape room experience. History lovers and puzzle solvers alike are in for a real treat! If you ask during a break in our service, one of our staff can take you down to check it out. It's a great photo op!
​
​What are your hours?
The restaurant is open Monday through Saturday, 11:00 AM to 7:00 PM. Closed Sundays. Hours are by appointment only for the Escape Room. For daily updates or schedule changes, check our Facebook Page or call the restaurant at 717-354-4986.
​
Where are you located?
Our address is 209 E Main Street, New Holland, PA—right in the heart of town, in a beautifully restored 1800s building.
​
Do you have parking?
Yes! There’s a public parking lot behind the restaurant (off of N Railroad Ave) and plenty of street parking nearby. Overflow parking is available next door at Trinity Lutheran Church (221 E Main Street, New Holland).
​​
Do you make donations?
We are able to make a limited number of donations per year. To request a donation for your event, classroom, or fundraiser, please fill out our donation request form here.
​
Is it true you've won awards and been on a restaurant episode?
Yes! We’ve been honored with multiple local “Best Of” awards over the years and were proudly featured on America’s Best Restaurants in 2024.
​
Where can I watch your America’s Best Restaurants episode?
You can watch the full episode here and see why our food, atmosphere, and escape room wowed the ABR team!
​
Dining Experience
Do you accept reservations?
We operate on a first-come, first-served basis. If you’re coming with a large group (7 or more), give us a call at 717-354-4986 and we’ll do our best to prepare for you.
​
Are you family-friendly?
Absolutely! Kids love the fun, cozy vibe—and our kid’s menu, ice cream treats, and friendly staff make it a hit for the whole family. Plus we have coloring sheets and a shelf of books and games to enjoy while you dine!
​
Do you offer high chairs or booster seats?
Yes, we’ve got both available.
​
Is the restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Yes, our space is fully accessible—including our restrooms.
​
What menu items are you known for?
Definitely our dill pickle soup, pretzel melts, hand-carved turkey sandwiches, homemade soups, and turkey & waffles. And don’t forget the ice cream sundaes! Vew our menus here.
​
Wait, what exactly is the Dill Pickle Soup?
Glad you asked! It's a cream of potato base with cooked carrots, diced dill pickles, and a kick of Old Bay Seasoning! Even if pickles aren't you're thing - it's worth trying!
​
What is The Stan Deen Combo?
In early 2025 we launched a new menu item, The Stan Deen Combo, featuring half a Garden Spot Melt, a cup of Chicken Corn Noodle, and a petite scoop of Milky Way ice cream. A portion of each Stan Deen Combo sold ($2!) will be donated to The Stan Deen Foundation. The Stan Deen Foundation exists to empower vulnerable youth through education and the arts. By partnering with local and national foundations, we seek to improve the quality of life for beneficiaries by investing in their education, artistic abilities, and mental health to build resilient, better informed, and more engaged individuals. Lickity Split owners, Mitch & Gina, are proud to be able to support this Foundation in honor of Stan and the personal connection they had with him.
Stan was a Lancaster County institution—beloved by generations of students and adults throughout the area and beyond. Stan’s remarkable life transformed countless individuals. With a seemingly endless supply of energy, enthusiasm, and optimism, all highlighted by his distinctive wit and charm, Stan truly lived each day to its fullest. His zest for life was unmatched, and he shared his joy with every person who crossed his path. Stan was at his best when he was bringing out the best in others. “If there is anything I could really encourage you all to do is have some visions and dreams for what you can become. Because everybody has been given certain abilities, certain talents and aspirations, and I would hope that you would use those to their fullest, wherever you go.” – Stan Deen
​
Do you accommodate food allergies or dietary restrictions?
We do our best! Just let a staff member know when you order and mention whether it's an allergy or a choice. We also offer gluten-free ice cream cones and dairy-free ice cream options. All of our sandwiches and wraps can also be made on gluten-free bread or a gluten-free wrap.
​​
What brand of ice cream do you serve?
We serve hand-dipped, premium-quality ice cream from Leiby’s—a Tamaqua, PA favorite with that old-fashioned flavor you love.
​
Can I order online?
Yes! Click here to order online for pickup.
​
Do you offer gift cards?
Sure do—stop in to purchase, order on our website, or give us a call at 717-354-4986!
​
Can I celebrate a birthday at Lickity Split?
Of course! We’re a popular spot for birthday meals and desserts—and we also host private events if you’re planning something bigger. Plus you get a FREE BIRTHDAY SUNDAE reminder when you join our VIP Email List.
Events & Catering
Do you host private events or parties?
Yes! Our restaurant can be transformed into a cozy first floor event space that’s perfect for showers, rehearsal dinners, birthdays, retirement parties, and more on Sundays when the restaurant is closed. Plus, we have a private venue space in the lower level that is available for bookings any day of the week! Learn more here.
​
How do I inquire about event rentals or catering?
Just fill out our event rental and catering inquiry form or give us a call—we’ll help you plan something special.
​
What kinds of events do you cater?
We do small meetings, corporate lunches, parties, and more. Our team loves being a part of your special events—big or small!.
​
Do you offer off-site catering?
Yes, we can assemble trays of food for you to pick-up and use at your off-site gathering. Pricing info can be found here.
​
Is outside food or cake allowed for events?
Yes, for private parties in our event space, you’re welcome to bring your own cake or special items. Just let us know in advance.
Ice Cream Truck & Cart
How can I book the ice cream truck or cart?
Just fill out our booking request form and we’ll get back to you with availability and pricing.
​
What types of events does the truck or cart attend?
Any and all! We do weddings, birthday parties, company events, fairs, employee appreciation, and food truck festivals all across Lancaster County.
​
Is there a minimum to book the truck or cart?
Yes—there is a minimum cost depending on distance, time, and number of servings. Pricing info can be found here.
​
What’s the difference between the ice cream truck and the ice cream cart?
The truck is great for larger events and outdoor festivals. The cart, added in 2025, is perfect for indoor set-up, during colder season, or for a more personal catering experience.
Escape Room
What is an escape room?
It’s a live-action adventure game where your group solves puzzles and clues to complete a mission—all in under 60 minutes!
​
Do I need to book in advance?
Yes, our escape room is reservation-based. Click here to book.
​
Is it kid-friendly?
The experience is best for ages 12 and up. It’s not scary, just full of puzzles, teamwork, and fun.
​
How many people can play at once?
Groups of 4–8 are ideal. However, we suggest a max of 15 people.
​
Is it wheelchair accessible?
We regret to share that it is not wheelchair accessible. Guests enter our event space from the front sidewalk on MAIN STREET and down the front steps to the lower-level space.
​​
Is the escape room inside the restaurant?
No - it's actually underneath! We have a private event space in the lower level and have incorporated the Escape Room experience throughout the room! This is also the location of the original 1800s jail cell inside our building—one of the most unique escape room features around.
Careers
Are you hiring? How can I apply?
We’re always looking for great people to join our team! Stop in for an application or fill out an online application. We’d love to meet you. Apply now!
​
What’s it like to work at Lickity Split?
Fun, fast-paced, friendly, and full of flavor! Many of our team members stay for years because it’s more than a job—it’s a family.